Fool is He who doesn’t do Better than His Father

en français

©haddadToni
The water evacuation system of the new R + buildings is embedded in the walls and blocked. The walls rot and breathe a permanent damp smell in the adjacent dormitories. Ankatso II, bâtiment R+ garçon

Ankatso 1« bloc 9, cite Ambohipo. many stuff needs to be repaired because our students’ accommodation is fucked… whether Ankatso or Ambohipo #urgent », a post on facebook by a student of Université d’Antananarivo mid February 2018.

©haddadToni ©Safidy
On the left, an improvised hairdressing room in the corridor; on the right, a 6 m2 room housing a family of 5. Ambohipo

Antananarivo is home of the primary university in Madagascar, an architectural emblem cradled in a valley. Next to it, the first unit of residences called Ankatso is home to 994 students. The conditions inside are hard and hazardous, but students have no choice and no voice.

Mino 20ans, étudiante en Génie Chimique. Vontovorona Ravaka 22ans, étudiant en science naturel. Ambohipo

Ankatso is on top of the hill, a well designed labyrinth of rooms, stairways, halls, a cantine and rooftop terraces that offer the visitor magnificent views of neighboring valleys, hills and marshland. The project was realized by a famous architect – Roland Simounet – in 1970 in order to accommodate 400-500 students.

La vie s’organise tant bien que mal pour les étudiants. Ambohipo A défaut d’un vrai restaurant universitaire, les chambres sont parfois transformées en gargote. Un privilège attribué à certains employés de l’université. Raissa 30ans Vontovorona.

The accommodation has been growing since then, each of the consecutive presidents of the republic except Mr. Hery R. has added or inaugurated a new site or building, none matches the original architecture nor standards.

CROUA (Centre Régional des Œuvres Universitaires d’Antananarivo) manages the current six accommodation sites. Mismanagement is evident, toilettes are clogged, pipes are leaking, water access is limited, haphazard homemade electrical wirings are all over, rotten dilapidated walls stink of humidity and doors broken. The students await an unannounced maintenance schedule.

©haddadToni
The comings and goings of the water cans punctuate the lives of residents. Water cuts are frequent and sources are remote. Despite the difficulties, Rova, 26, a mathematics student, finds time to take care of her small green space.Ankatso I, Bloc Paradisa

A president, usually a current student, reports to CROUA on the number of inhabitants in a sector or floor. He/She is chosen by the residents of this sector and the point of contact for any grievance from the students. In addition, they enforce the rules set forth by CROUA and the respective tribe president.

Une cuisine flambant neuf de 70 m2, un évier déjà bouché, 3 prises de courant seulement pour 80 étudiants et un CROUA sans budget de maintenance. Pas étonnant si les étudiants improvisent et finissent par détruire les lieux. Ankatso II, bâtiment R+ fille Diviser pour mieux régner ! La ségrégation ethnique est bien présente dans les résidences universitaires d’Antananarivo. Les blocs sont divisés par ville, région ou tribu. Ambatomaro

A tribe president is a studen chosen by his born tribe. In turn, these presidents report to CROUA of their needs within their respective student community.

To share a room here, the price per bed varies from 7,000ar (1.8euros) to 80,000ar (20euros) per year paid to CROUA. To rent a room, a one time bribe to a president of 3,000,000ar to 5,000,000ar is a must. 27% of the current population are squatters who used to be students or are in relation with one.

©haddadToni ©Safidy
“Ambatomaro is a 30-minute walk from the university, there is no bus. Here the water is off all day and students have to wait until night to be able to fill the jerycans”
Faniry 20 years old, student in Ambatomaro
The goal is to finish the studies but the harsh reality of the cities slows down the students. Vontovorona

Students do not complain. Some are content, many don’t speak afraid of losing their refuge, others are pressured not to, while a few have tried once and gave up…

It is hard for a reporter to be emotionally detached from the subject under investigation, but amidst the stench of clogged toilettes and the tangle of wires and traffic of water gallons, it was impossible to accept the response: “this is normal, this is Madagascar”.

Normal is not risking your life every time you plug the heater to prepare dinner. Normal is not accepting being robbed on campus. Normal is sleeping under a roof sure it will not collapse. Normal is to have ownership of shared space, do the necessary to maintain it like home, and pass on to the next.

©haddadToni ©Safidy
The residents are totally out of place. A homemade electrical installation that risks short-circuiting at any time. Ankatso I, Bloc Révolution

 Antananarivo © 2018

[a collaborative work and message with Safidy Andrianantenaina]

READ NEXT ARTICLE

,

,

,

,

More Galleries For You

,

,

HOME

,

,